ChatGPT & Gemini: Which agency should you choose to manage your visibility on AI chatbots?
A brand’s visibility in responses generated by artificial intelligence has become a new strategic challenge for marketing departments. However, being regularly mentioned by ChatGPT in no way guarantees an equivalent presence on Gemini. A company may enjoy good visibility on one of these platforms whilst remaining largely absent from the other, without necessarily realising it.
This disparity can be explained, in particular, by the differences between the ecosystems, the sources of information and the mechanisms utilised by each model to generate its responses. This is why an AI visibility strategy cannot be limited to a blanket approach to ‘chatbots’. ChatGPT and Gemini require separate analysis and optimisations tailored to their specific characteristics.
Key points to remember:
-
ChatGPT and Gemini are based on different
approaches: ChatGPT relies on its own ecosystem and ad hoc web searches, whilst Gemini benefits from close integration with the Google ecosystem. -
SEO remains a key factor for Gemini
Good organic search rankings on Google are an asset for boosting visibility in Gemini, although they do not automatically guarantee recommendations. -
GEO complements organic
SEO . Simply ranking well on Google is no longer enough: you must also work on enhancing your brand’s understanding, authority and presence within AI-generated responses. -
AI visibility must be measured on a platform-by-platform
basis . Sources, mentions and recommendations may vary between ChatGPT and Gemini. Separate monitoring enables you to identify opportunities and areas for improvement. -
An SEO + GEO agency must be proficient in both environments
The right partner must combine SEO expertise, content optimisation, brand authority development and visibility monitoring across the various AI platforms.
In summary, ChatGPT and Gemini require a differentiated yet complementary approach. To build sustainable visibility in AI responses, a business must rely on a solid SEO foundation, strengthen its online authority and regularly measure its presence on each platform. The challenge is to build an SEO + GEO strategy capable of covering the full range of new search journeys.
ChatGPT and Gemini: two different approaches
ChatGPT: an independent research and recommendation ecosystem
ChatGPT draws on the knowledge acquired during its training, but can also utilise web searches to provide up-to-date and well-researched answers. This capability enables it to cross-reference different sources of information, identify relevant parties and make recommendations based on the context of the query.
For brands, therefore, the challenge goes beyond simply optimising their own website. It is about developing a consistent presence across the entire information ecosystem: expert content, third-party publications, brand mentions and authoritative sources within their sector. These various signals help to strengthen their credibility and their potential to be cited in the generated responses.
Gemini: visibility closely linked to the Google ecosystem
Gemini benefits from deep integration within the Google environment, particularly through its search capabilities and the various services within the ecosystem. This close integration creates significant links between organic search and visibility in AI-generated results.
A technically robust website that is properly indexed and ranks well for strategic search queries therefore has a solid foundation on which to build its visibility in this environment. However, a good ranking on Google does not automatically guarantee a mention in Gemini: the relevance of the content, its reliability and its ability to accurately meet users’ search intent remain crucial factors.
ChatGPT and Gemini: a comparison table
| Criterion | ChatGPT | Gemini |
|---|---|---|
| Ecosystem | Conversational model with web search capabilities | Conversational model integrated into the Google ecosystem |
| Sources used | Knowledge of the model and web sources, depending on the features used | Model knowledge and information from Google’s search services and capabilities |
| GEO Issues | Brand authority, external references, expert content and reliable sources | SEO fundamentals, content quality, indexing and brand authority |
| Sensitivity to traditional SEO | Varies depending on the features used | Strong synergy with the fundamentals of SEO |
💡 Good to know: A strong SEO ranking on Google provides a solid foundation for boosting your visibility on Gemini, but does not automatically guarantee that you’ll appear in its responses. For ChatGPT, organic search remains useful too, but must be complemented by specific work on brand authority, content and third-party sources that the model is likely to draw upon.
Why is visibility on ChatGPT and Gemini becoming strategic?
The way people search has clearly changed. Before, a prospective customer would type their query into Google, open five tabs, compare three websites and end up with 27 tabs open without really knowing how. Nowadays, they can leave much of this work to ChatGPT, Gemini or Perplexity and ask directly which option to choose, which solution to prioritise or which brand best meets their needs.
And that’s a game-changer. AI no longer just has to find your pages; it has to understand who you are, what you do and why you’re relevant to a specific topic.
What should a good agency specialising in ChatGPT and Gemini offer?
On the ChatGPT side
To boost your visibility on ChatGPT, the key is to send the right signals of trust. Clear content, clearly demonstrated expertise and a brand that features in credible third-party sources help to build a stronger online presence.
And as ChatGPT can also retrieve up-to-date information online, a brand’s visibility can change over time. Being visible today does not guarantee that you will be visible tomorrow. Regular monitoring is therefore essential to measure changes in visibility, identify opportunities and adjust the strategy based on the results observed.
Gemini side
Here, the agency must have a genuine SEO culture, in the traditional sense of the term: domain authority, the technical quality of the website and consistency in Google’s indexing. It must also monitor developments relating to Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode, which are gradually reshaping search journeys and the rules governing organic visibility. These new formats require SEO strategies to be adapted in order to continue capturing the attention of internet users, even beyond traditional search results.
A common content framework
In both cases, the fundamentals remain the same: clear, factual, up-to-date content, and a credible presence outside your own website. It is this foundation that then allows you to tailor your strategy to each platform, without having to start from scratch every time.
5 questions to check whether an agency really knows how to handle both
- How would you rate my current visibility on ChatGPT and Gemini separately?
- What specific distinctions do you make between a strategy designed for one or the other?
- How do you keep up to date with updates to ChatGPT’s search function?
- In your opinion, how does my standard Google SEO affect my presence on Gemini?
- Have you ever supported a brand on both platforms simultaneously, achieving measurable results?
If the agency you’re dealing with gives the same generic answer for both platforms, it’s a safe bet that they haven’t really looked into the matter properly.
💡 Advice from our experts:
Don’t simply replicate your SEO strategy on ChatGPT and Gemini
The two platforms do not necessarily draw on the same sources or use the same selection mechanisms. Maintain a common SEO and editorial foundation, but adapt your optimisations to the specific characteristics of each environment.
Build your authority beyond your own website
Visibility in AI responses doesn’t depend solely on your own content. Build your presence on credible third-party sites: specialist media, comparison sites, leading reference sites and industry publications. These sources help to strengthen your brand’s credibility.
Structure your content to make it easier for AI to understand
Prioritise factual, accurate and regularly updated content. Organise your pages around specific questions, provide direct answers and highlight your expertise. The aim is to enable AI models to clearly understand your business and your areas of expertise.
Track your visibility separately on each platform
Don’t just test a few prompts from time to time. Build a panel of queries representative of your business challenges and regularly measure your citation rate, share of voice, rankings, the context of mentions and the sources used by ChatGPT and Gemini.
Don’t overlook developments at Google and in generative AI
AI Overviews, Google’s AI Mode and developments in web search within ChatGPT are gradually changing search journeys. Incorporate these developments into your SEO and GEO monitoring to anticipate changes and adjust your priorities.
Key takeaway: ChatGPT and Gemini should not be treated as a single channel for visibility. An effective GEO strategy relies on understanding the specific characteristics of each platform, whilst capitalising on SEO fundamentals. An SEO + GEO agency must be able to measure, compare and optimise a brand’s presence across all these environments to boost its visibility and generate new business opportunities.
Do ChatGPT and Gemini work in the same way as Google?
Do ChatGPT and Gemini work in the same way as Google?
Not really. And that’s precisely where things get interesting… and sometimes a bit of a challenge. A traditional search engine organises pages in a list of results based on their relevance to a query. A generative search engine works differently: it interprets a query, draws on the information at its disposal, may consult online sources, and constructs a summarised response. It can thus mention brands, compare solutions or recommend certain providers without necessarily repeating Google’s top results.
Consequently, ranking first for a keyword does not automatically guarantee that a brand will be recommended in an AI response. Conversely, a brand may be mentioned by ChatGPT or Gemini without appearing in the top positions on the corresponding SERP.
That does not, however, mean that SEO is becoming less important. Content quality, page accessibility, website authority and the brand’s online presence remain key factors. The challenge now is to work on improving visibility both in traditional search results and in AI-generated responses.
SEO and AI visibility: what are the differences?
| Criteria | SEO | GEO (AI visibility) |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Ranking pages in search results | Feature and recommend a brand in AI-generated responses |
| Targeted queries | Keywords and search intent | Questions, prompts and conversational queries |
| Content levers | Semantic relevance, structure and page optimisation | Clarity of answers, factual accuracy, expertise and the structure of the content |
| Authority | Backlinks, popularity and domain authority | Brand mentions, citations and appearances in credible third-party sources |
| Performance indicators | Rankings, impressions, clicks and organic traffic | Mentions, citations, AI share of voice, positioning in responses and traffic generated by AI |
| Business objective | Generate qualified traffic and conversions | Building brand awareness, generating referrals and creating opportunities through AI platforms |
Which digital marketing agency should you choose in France?
The right partner obviously depends on your situation. A company that is already very strong in SEO will not have the same needs as an e-commerce business looking to quickly integrate AI-driven visibility into its entire customer acquisition strategy.
An SEO + GEO agency to capitalise on what you already have
Do you already have a solid website, high-performing content and strong SEO authority? There’s no need to start from scratch. An SEO + GEO agency can build on this foundation to work on content structure, structured data, brand authority and semantic understanding. The idea is simple: to evolve your SEO strategy so that it also speaks the language of generative engines.
A GEO pure-play consultancy
Agencies specialising exclusively in GEO may be worth considering if you want to carry out rapid testing, set up in-depth tracking or analyse your presence on ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. They are particularly well-suited to businesses that already have the necessary teams in place to turn recommendations into action in the areas of SEO, content, data or customer acquisition.
Ad’s up: a reading experience that covers every platform
At Ad’s up Consulting, AI visibility is never limited to a single model. We have developed a dedicated GEO offering, designed to cover the entire conversational ecosystem, rather than relying on a single platform to the detriment of others. At the same time, the team continues to support its clients with traditional SEO, which remains a crucial foundation for visibility on Gemini in particular.
Would you like to find out where you stand with ChatGPT and Gemini? The Ad’s up team can review your current situation with you and lay the groundwork for a roadmap.
FAQ – ChatGPT, Gemini and GEO Agency
Yes, it is possible to work on the factors that promote understanding, authority and a brand’s presence within the information ecosystem used by generative engines. However, no reputable agency can guarantee a specific mention.
SEO primarily aims to improve visibility in search engine results. GEO focuses on presence in the responses generated by generative engines. The two approaches are complementary.
The citation rate, AI share of voice, the number of prompts in which a brand appears, associated sources, the context of mentions and traffic from AI platforms are all good starting points.
It is useful to measure both separately, as the responses and sources may differ. The underlying strategy, however, remains largely the same: to build a recognisable, credible and well-researched brand.